Poll from stdin, but windows is windows

Help
1

I would like to read from stdin, but only if the user actually wrote something.
I don’t really want to open another thread just for this so I tried a implementation from another ziggit post: Simple solution to read a byte with timeout

So at the end I wrote this code:

const resultOrError = io.operateTimeout(.{.file_read_streaming = .{
        .data = &.{&readBuffer},
        .file = .stdin(),
}}, .{ .duration = .{ .raw = .zero , .clock = .awake } }) catch |err| {
    if (err == error.Timeout) return;
    std.log.err("Error while reading from stdin: {t}", .{err});
    return;
};
const result = resultOrError.file_read_streaming catch |err| {
    std.log.err("Error while reading from stdin: {t}", .{err});
    return;
};
if (result == 0) return;
... // do something with the input

This works on linux and I hoped that it would also work on windows, but when I tried it I got this error:
Error while reading from stdin: ConcurrencyUnavailable
This is because of this line in std/Io/Threaded.zig:

if (o.file.flags.nonblocking) {
    ...
} else {
    if (concurrency) return error.ConcurrencyUnavailable;
   ...

I am not that deep into the everything going on with how windows etc handle the stdin, but is there a way for me to make this work on linux and on windows? Or can maybe someone point me to an issue I need to look out for, so I can just mark this as currently not possible on windows. (or maybe there is already a way on 0.17.0?)
(I do want to say that this is my first time trying to write such a program, so I may miss some implementation that would be better / would solve this)

2

Threaded uses synchronous IO on Windows. I don’t think it’s possible without writing your own platform specific code.

3

Asynchronous (non-blocking) reading from stdin is a pretty hard problem to solve on Windows. The handle is not open as OVERLAPPED, and any other API might block. Honestly, the best solution is a separate thread that does blocking reads and posts results to an event/queue. It sucks, but I don’t know of a better solution.

1 Like